Are German Courts the “Spoilsport” of the “Divisional Game” when it comes to Preliminary Injunction Requests?

Written By

annika lueckemann module
Dr. Annika Lückemann, LL.M. (Virginia)

Counsel
Germany

As a Counsel in our Intellectual Property Group, I represent national and international companies in all matters of intellectual property. My particular focus lies on litigating patents from all technical areas, including the co-ordination of international patent disputes.

If a patentee undertakes actions with respect to a patent of the same patent family (e.g. waiving the parent patent of a divisional patent), this is often negatively characterised as playing the “Divisional Game”. We don’t want to go into the details of this but rather focus on the impact of such actions on a request for a preliminary injunction (“PI”). Two Appeal Courts in Germany have dealt with such a scenario and came to different conclusions. While the Munich Appeal Court generally seems more open to assume an abusive behavior (speaking against the grant of a PI), the Düsseldorf Appeal Court focuses on the timing of such strategic actions.

Background

Assume a parent patent, which survived opposition proceedings before the EPO. Patentee then decides to waive the parent patent during the course of the opposition appeal proceedings. In the meantime, a divisional patent is granted. Said divisional is asserted in PI proceedings against a competitor.

In our case, two PI requests have been filed successively: one before the positive EPO decision regarding the divisional patent (unsuccessful) and one after said EPO decision (successful).

View the full article in our BioTalk blog.

 

Latest insights

More Insights
featured image

Applications for provisional measures before the UPC – what may be granted?

5 minutes Mar 31 2025

Read More
featured image

English Court of Appeal uphold decision declaring that MSD had used “Merck” in breach of Court Order

3 minutes Mar 28 2025

Read More
Curiosity line teal background

China Releases Comprehensive Draft Data Exclusivity Rules for Comments

5 minutes Mar 24 2025

Read More